9 Best Store-bought Pizza Sauce Brands

Best Store-bought Pizza Sauce

Best Store-bought Pizza Sauce

Tired of settling for store-bought pizza sauce that falls short of flavor? Well, you don’t have to anymore! With so many different brands and flavors out there, there’s bound to be one that fits your taste buds perfectly. Whether you’re looking for a traditional classic or something new and innovative, we’ve got the options covered.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss the nine best store-bought pizza sauces that will kick your pizza game up a notch! From organic varieties with no preservatives to some packed with unique herbed cheeses, read on to find your perfect match today!

Best store-bought pizza sauce

Yo Mama’s Keto Marinara Pasta and Pizza Sauce

Yo Mama's Keto Marinara Pasta and Pizza Sauce

Our award-winning, old-world Italian recipe hails directly from Grandma’s real homemade recipe. Enjoy a truly authentic Italian pasta sauce made with protein-packed organic chicken stock, fresh non-GMO tomatoes, fresh garlic, and aromatic basil – all while remaining guilt-free. With no added sugar, low sodium, and preservative-free ingredients, Yo Mama’s Gourmet Marinara Magnifica is a wholesome treat that everyone can enjoy guilt-free.

Experience an amazingly versatile marinara that lights up any occasion without getting off your keto lifestyle! Exquisite tomato sauce is ideal for topping your favorite pizza or lasagna recipes, adding flavor to cooked veggies, or making classic pasta dishes extra special. Plus it was victorious in a blind taste test of the three leading premium brands – so you can trust it will deliver mindblowing flavor every single time!

Bring a touch of healthy indulgence to your kitchen with Yo Mama’s Keto Marinara Pasta and Pizza Sauce – ready to top any dish with incredible tastes of slow-simmered tradition in just the click of a button!

Standard benefits:

  • Low-sodium, preservative-free, Non-GMO.
  • Paleo-friendly, low-carb, and compatible with the Whole 30 lifestyles
  • Beat the leading brands in a blind taste test
  • No sugar added
  • Fresh ingredients
  • Keto Certified and Paleo Certified
  • Gluten-free, dairy-free.


  • Very tasty and low carb and low sugar.
  • Great flavor AND conforms with a keto eating plan
  • This sauce is the perfect healthy flavor that doesn’t require extra additions.
  • Yo Mama’s pasta sauce is a delicious, low-sodium alternative that can be blended with zero-sodium sauces to create a flavorful dish.
  • The textures and colors are great.


  • These are very small bottles so it is quite expensive.
  • Could be a little chunkier with tomatoes and onions.

Fix Hot Sauce Variety Pack

Fix Hot Sauce Variety Pack

Introducing the Fix Hot Sauce Variety Pack, an exciting adventure into the world of gourmet sauces made for those that love things just a little bit spicier! We’ve taken all-natural ingredients and flavorful peppers from regions in South East Asia and crafted each sauce with a unique flavor profile for you to explore.

First, Gourmet Sriracha Sauce includes only natural ingredients and flavorful peppers that will make your taste buds dance. You’re sure to enjoy this classic heat coupled with hints of sweetness that make it so alluring.

Next, Gourmet Hoisin Sauce features organic green chili peppers blended in small batches for nuanced flavor profiles. Be prepared for a delightful mix of heat with hints of tangy sourness that balance its flavor perfectly.

Our Sriracha Green Sauce puts a spin on classic Sriracha with more subtle flavors, while still maintaining the same depth of flavor. Here, you’ll enjoy bursts of heat along with subtle notes of citrusy lemon and mild garlic for a flavorful experience that won’t overwhelm your palette. Lastly, Habanero Hot Sauce is a perfect combination of habanero chili peppers mixed with ginger combined with just seven natural ingredients – no preservatives! Feel the explosive heat complemented by hints of sweet and sour notes in every bottle!

The story behind Fix Hot Sauce Variety Pack starts after the founder took an inspirational journey through Vietnam. During their travels they were moved by the South Asian sun-grown chili peppers, inspiring them to recreate this incredible experience and share it across the world using their family recipe passed down from generation to generation. So join us on this hot sauce adventure today – we promise you won’t regret it!

Standard benefits:

  • 100% vegan and gluten-free.
  • Made with all-natural ingredients.
  • Spice up meals with unique and delicious sauces.
  • Enjoy flavors from around the world in your own home.
  • Transform ordinary dishes into gourmet creations.


  • This sriracha has an organic, flavorful balance of sweetness and heat, making it perfect for adding to pizza, ramen, burgers, eggs, and other soups.
  • This sauce is versatile and tasty.
  • Fix hot sauce elevates the flavors of any dish and has a lasting heat and depth of flavor that makes it stand out from other brands.
  • Fix hot sauce is a flavorful blend of heat, garlic, and tang designed to enhance dishes.
  • This sauce has a great sriracha-peppery taste and pairs well with any dish, making it a must-try for anyone looking for an amazing flavor experience.


  • The spice level of the dish is not hot, but somewhere between mild and medium.
  • Too much garlic flavor can make it difficult to enjoy garlicky foods. The garlic flavor of this product can be a surprise, but should still be tried with other foods to give it a chance.

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

At Don Pepino, they have been proudly making superior pizza sauces for over half a century. preservative-free recipes are carefully crafted using vine-ripened Jersey tomatoes and a signature blend of spices and garlic. unique process locks in the natural taste and flavor of ingredients to produce delicious ingredients found nowhere else. That’s why millions of families have trusted Don Pepino to deliver the perfect sauce for their home-cooked pizza creations.

Here at Don Pepino, they take pride in creating truly irresistible recipes using all-natural ingredients. The sauce is vegetarian-friendly, cholesterol free, and full of thick texture and flavourful richness. They guarantee that your family will love it as much as theirs has over the decades! Whether you’re hosting a simple family dinner or throwing a pizza party, your guests will be delighted with the authentic total of Don Pepino pizza sauce on their pie!

Standard benefits:

  • Made with fresh vine-ripened tomatoes
  • Cholesterol free
  • Rich in taste and texture
  • Get a mouthwatering pizza sauce in less time.
  • Enjoy a delicious, Italian-inspired flavor.
  • Rich and delicious taste
  • Made with all-natural ingredients
  • Authentic pizza sauce recipe since 1950.
  • A perfect blend of tomatoes and spices for a rich flavor.
  • Made without paste, purees, preservatives, starches, gums, sugar, artificial color, citric acid, or fillers


  • It is a slightly sweet sauce. 
  • Great flavor and texture.
  • A great and versatile sauce, this is a go-to item in many kitchens.
  • This pizza sauce is the perfect balance of bold flavor and appropriate consistency, enough to provide a generous spread for two 14″ pizzas.
  • This sauce is a great choice for pizza, subs, pasta, and more, as it comes in an easy-to-use pull tab can and has less sodium than other sauces while offering better flavor.


  • Always keep an eye on the price as it can fluctuate significantly.
  • It doubled in price in a year!

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

For the health-conscious pizza lover, Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce is an unbeatable choice! This sauce is USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified. With wholesome ingredients like tomatoes with no cholesterol, and lightly seasoned with sea salt, oregano, onion powder, black pepper, and garlic powder, this organic pizza sauce is guaranteed to be full of delicious flavor in every bite. The best part? It won’t take hours out of your day to make – just open the can and you’re ready to go!

High-quality tomatoes from California are harvested at their peak flavor and cooked down into a rich and savory 3-in-1 sauce that works as both a tomato paste and pizza sauce. Not only can you liven up your homemade pizzas with Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce but you can also use it as a base for soups, stews, or chili. Easy to store in your pantry, get the guilt-free satisfaction of knowing that you’re using only organic ingredients for all your favorite recipes. Enjoy the taste and nutrition of Muir Glen organic tomatoes today!

Standard benefits:

  • Contains all-natural ingredients
  • USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified
  • Cholesterol Free
  • Packed with flavor and nutrients from fresh vegetables
  • Free of gluten for a variety of dietary restrictions.


  • This organic pizza sauce has the best taste.
  • With the right ingredients and techniques, one can enjoy delicious homemade pizza or alternative recipes like pizza pasta and pizza-style grilled tortillas.
  • One can of Brooklyn pizza is equivalent to three small pizzas, or two large slices.
  • Not too sweet, not too spicy, and just the right consistency for pizza.
  • This gluten-free pizza sauce has a great flavor and is worth the price, making it better than a typical pizza shop slice.


  • Although the product tastes great, some of the cans were dented.
  • The price has increased significantly.

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce

Our award-winning Italian recipe has been crafted for over 68 years, embodying the intense flavor and passion of its creators. Feel the zesty taste of naturally plucked tomatoes at their juiciest peak, combined with imported extra-virgin olive oil and Pecorino Romano cheese for an intense burst of flavors.

Our authentic Italian pizza sauce is a true family classic that has stood the test of time since 1952. Perfectly balanced, it doesn’t have added sugars, GMOs, or preservatives, making it a balanced choice with each bite. Plus, this 8 oz can make up to two 12-inch pizzas with a delicious sauce.

Bring the exquisite flavors of Italy to your kitchen shelf with Pastorelli Pizza Sauce – voted 5 grand gold medals by “being in a class by itself”! With this pizza pasta sauce on hand, you’ll always be ready for flavorful homemade pizzas.

Standard benefits:

  • Award-winning recipe for an unbeatable taste
  • Made with fresh San Marzano-style tomatoes
  • Enhanced by imported Pecorino Romano cheese and extra-virgin olive oil
  • Non-GMO, no added sugars, gluten-free, BPA-free, and preservative-free.


  • This sauce is perfect for making pizza and provides great flavor without being acidic or sweet.
  • Works perfectly, tastes great, and goes a long way.
  • This NYC pizza sauce is zesty, tangy, and packed with flavor, with a Sicilian oregano sweetness that makes it stand out from typical store-bought sauces.
  • This pizza sauce is loved by adults and children for its deliciousness and versatility in homemade and grilled pizzas.
  • Also good for a quick meal of pasta or bread dipping.


  • Those who prefer a sweeter and more intensely tomato-flavored pizza sauce should keep searching.
  •  This pizza sauce is expensive compared to other similar products.

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Pizza Sauce

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Pizza Sauce

Introducing 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Pizza Sauce – a delicious classic made with certified USDA organic and vegan ingredients. The sauce is full of flavor without any added sugar for a truly one-of-a-kind taste.

Each jar is packed with premium ingredients like organic tomato puree, extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, onions, onion powder, garlic powder, oregano, black pepper, and basil. All of these are carefully blended to give you the ideal pizza sauce. As a bonus, it has no sugar added- so it’s healthier too! It’s the perfect addition to your healthy homemade pizza night.

At 365 by Whole Foods Market they pride themselves on the trust and quality of all products. They ensure that each jar meets rigorous quality standards which prohibits over 100 ingredients from being used both in food and in supplements.

365 Everyday Value products offer premium ingredients that meet all Whole Foods Market quality standards without compromising on price or taste. So don’t just settle for store-bought sauces or canned alternatives; add some zest to your next meal with this trusted organic pizza sauce from 365 by Whole Foods Market and you’ll be glad you did!

Standard benefits:

  • Contains no added sugar (not a low-calorie food)
  • Quality standards prohibit over 100 ingredients for both food and supplements.
  • Includes ingredients with premium quality standards
  • Certified organic and natural ingredients.
  • Fully tested to meet Whole Foods Market standards.
  • Enjoy the peace of mind that comes with knowing your food is safe and healthy.


  • This sauce is great for a quick pizza night, made with organic ingredients and flavorful olive oil.
  • This product is tasty and free of preservatives, making it a great choice for repeat purchases.
  • This jar of marinara sauce is perfect for pizza and pasta, as it already includes oregano and comes in a convenient size at an affordable price.
  • This pizza sauce will transform a homemade pizza into something so delicious that it cannot be replicated with homemade ingredients.
  • Great pizza sauce with full flavor that can be enhanced with fresh or dried herbs.


  • This organic pizza sauce lacked spices and had a mostly tomato flavor, so additional herbs were added to enhance the taste.
  • Reduce salt content for improved flavor.

Rao’s Homemade Classic Pizza Sauce

Rao's Homemade Classic Pizza Sauce

At Rao’s Homemade, they believe that when it comes to pizza sauce nothing beats making it at home. That’s why they crafted Rao’s Homemade Classic Pizza Sauce – a delicious combination of Italian peeled tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, olive oil, oregano, basil, garlic, and salt that is great for creating restaurant-style pizzas in the comfort of your own home. Plus with this 13-ounce jar, you get plenty of servings to enjoy!

Our all-natural pizza sauce is made with high-quality ingredients plus no added sugar for those who are watching their carbs. They don’t skimp on flavor either – their tried and true recipes have made us famous! With the classic flavor and consistency, you can enjoy a delicious dinner every night without spending hours in the kitchen. No matter what type of crust you choose –traditional or even the popular cauliflower crusts– their pizza sauce will pair deliciously well with any recipe.

Rao’s Homemade Classic Pizza Sauce is proud to be vegan, vegetarian, and Paleo diet friendly so everyone can join in on the deliciousness! So when your cravings for homestyle pizzas arise reach for Rao’s Homemade Classic Pizza Sauce to take your meal from blah to wow. And if you want different flavors besides the classic Pizza Sauce try some of other pasta sauces such as Marinara and Tomato Basil!

Standard benefits:

All natural, premium quality ingredients

100% Italian tomatoes

Versatile for any type of pizza crust

Slow-cooked in small batches to concentrate the flavor.

Made with high-quality ingredients like basil, Italian tomatoes, olive oil, onions, and garlic

No added sugar or starches

Keto-friendly and carb conscious.


  • Pizza dough, either homemade or store-bought, can be easily flavored with this product for an easy dinner idea.
  • Highly recommended for its great taste and health benefits, this product is worth the price.
  • Pizza sauce sold in a jar is thicker and richer than other sauces, making it ideal for the pasta to give a New York Italian-style flavor.
  • Rao’s Pizza Sauce is made from scratch to provide an easy and delicious option for cooking for large groups.
  • This jarred pizza sauce offers a delicious balance of olive oil, crushed tomatoes, and sweetness.
  • Rao’s pasta sauce is better than pizza sauce and can be used to make a delicious low-carb tortilla pizza.


  • This pizza sauce is very tasty, but it is priced too high to be a regular purchase.
  • The jar is pretty small.

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese is the perfect way to make pizza night quick and easy. With fresh, Italian-flavored tomato sauce and zesty cheese, you’ll get all the authentic flavor for a fraction of the effort. Plus, each pizza kit contains enough crust mix for two 12” pizzas, giving everyone a chance to customize their meals! You can use this convenient pizza sauce with your favorite toppings or just top it with cheese – it’s whatever your family needs. And for those trying to maintain a low-carb lifestyle, worry not – the pizza sauce has only 3g net carbs per serving (4g total carbs minus 1g dietary fiber)!

Chef Boyardee makes it easy to enjoy home-cooked meals without spending hours in the kitchen. In a convenient and easy-to-use package, you’ll get an unbeatable combination of quality ingredients suitable for adults and kids alike. Plus, you’ll have one less dish to clean up afterward since you bake these delicious pizzas in your oven at home. Ready whenever hunger strikes, Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese is sure to become a regular rotation in your meal planning!

Standard benefits:

  • Authentic Italian flavor in under three minutes.
  • Low carb and low calorie for a healthier pizza night.
  • Conveniently make two large pizzas with one pizza kit
  • Make your custom pizza with your favorite toppings
  • Enjoy authentic Italian flavor without the hassle of making your sauce
  • No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives.


  • Makes awesome pizza tastier, providing you know how to make awesome pizza.
  • This Pizza sauce evokes fond memories of childhood and is an excellent value for the money.
  • The sauce is smooth and without chunks, making it suitable for those with sensory issues.
  • It’s the same glorious, delicious, pizza sauce.
  • Chef Boyardee pizza kits in a box were a childhood favorite for many, and now with one can of sauce, two large pizzas can be made with the same nostalgic flavor.


  • Some cans received had severe dents and were unusable.
  • The saltiness of the sauce is not overpowering when it is spread out over a pizza crust, but it is too thin and needs to be cooked down before use.

Carbone Marinara Pasta Sauce

Carbone Marinara Pasta Sauce

Carbone Marinara Pasta Sauce is the perfect addition to your kitchen! So you can enjoy a restaurant-quality Italian meal any night of the week. The pasta sauces are made with only the highest quality and freshest ingredients like all-natural, imported Italian tomatoes and fresh basil, garlic, herbs, and spices resulting in an elevated flavor profile that surpasses homemade spaghetti sauce.

Each jar of Carbone Sauce is artfully crafted to deliver a flavor experience that has been slow-cooked in small batches to ensure consistent quality. They know life involves many dietary restrictions and preferences so the sauces are all-natural, plant-based, gluten-free, non-GMO, Kosher certified, Keto friendly, and sugar-free with only 5 net carbs per serving — no compromise on taste here!

These two (2) packs of Marinara Pasta Sauce are ideal for exploring more of Carbone’s delicious recipes without any limitations — you’ll love their Tomato Basil, Arrabbiata, and Roasted Garlic pasta sauce flavors! Enjoy a unique flavor experience with Carbone Marinara Pasta Sauce today!

Standard benefits:

  • All sauces are natural, plant-based, gluten-free, non-GMO, Kosher, Keto, and sugar-free.
  • Enjoy delicious, high-quality Italian-American cuisine.


  • This Arrabbiata sauce is a delicious and spicy way to add flavor to food for those with a keto lifestyle.
  • Great value, has a nice variety, and awesome flavor.
  • Great sauce for pasta and as a base for pizza. Very pleasant taste.
  • This jar sauce is an affordable and flavorful option, with authentic ingredients that rival homemade.
  • This jarred sauce is pricey but delicious, with a variety of flavors that have allowed us to find new and exciting dishes to make.
  • The marinara sauce has a great balance of sweet and sour flavor, making it perfect for pasta, pizza, dips, and spreads, and even better than store-bought brands.


  • Despite its great taste, this product stains everything it touches, leading to its eventual disposal.
  • This expensive tomato sauce has a chunky texture with small pearls of tomatoes.

What to Look for in Store-Bought Pizza Sauces?


Simpler is better when it comes to ingredients. Opt for sauces with shorter lists of ingredients, typically starting with a tomato base and including spices, oil, and a preservative. Frank Linn, owner/chef of Frankly Pizza in Kensington, Maryland, advises avoiding sauces with numerous unknown ingredients. If you can’t pronounce it, you may not want to consume it. Stick to sauces with the fewest ingredients for the best choice.

High Sodium Content in Pre-Packaged Foods: Avoid Excessive Salt Intake

When considering pre-packaged foods, keep in mind that sodium levels can often be elevated. Take a moment to review the nutrition facts panel before reaching for that jar of pizza sauce. Being aware of the existing salt content allows you to exercise caution and avoid inadvertently adding unnecessary salt when assembling your pizza. Remember, even popular pizza toppings can be surprisingly high in sodium. Stay informed and make healthier choices.

Type of Sauce

Choosing the right sauce can transform your pizza experience. Whether you prefer a creamy white pizza, a classic margarita pizza with a touch of sweetness or a flavorful pesto pizza, the type of sauce you select is vital. For a mouthwatering white pizza, opt for a cream-based sauce. If you crave a margarita pizza, stick with a traditional tomato sauce blended with a hint of sweetness. And if a pesto pizza is calling your name, explore the world of pre-made pestos. Elevate your pizza game by selecting the perfect sauce.

Sweet Pizza Sauce

Indulge in the perfect balance of sweetness in every bite of the sweet pizza sauce. Made from vine-ripened tomatoes and just the right amount of added sugar, this sauce adds a delightful touch to your favorite pizzas.

Pair the sweet sauce with pineapple, vegetables, sausages, or bacon for a delectable combination that will satisfy your cravings. However, be aware that it may not complement more intense flavors as the contrasting sweet and tangy aromas might not blend harmoniously.

Experience pizza like never before with the sweet pizza sauce. Order now and elevate your pizza game to a new level of deliciousness.

Spicy Pizza Sauces

This is a tantalizing blend of spices, vinegar, hot sauce, and butter.

The flavorful sauce is the perfect balance of heat and savory goodness. It pairs perfectly with classic toppings like pepperoni and beef, creating a bold and satisfying culinary experience. But why stop there? For a touch of sweetness, try adding bacon, mushrooms, or sausages to your pizza creation.

And for those who crave an extra kick, don’t forget to sprinkle on some red pepper flakes.

Elevate your pizza game with Spicy Pizza Sauces – guaranteed to ignite your taste buds and leave you craving more.

Pesto Pizza Sauce

Indulge in the exquisite flavors of pesto on your next pizza venture. Pesto pizza sauce boasts a delightful blend of roasted pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, olive oil, basil, and garlic. Say goodbye to the monotony of cheese pizza and opt for the tantalizing alternative of pesto pizza sauce. Enhance your creation with the addition of tomatoes and chicken as delectable toppings. Elevate your pizza experience with the irresistible allure of pesto.

Basil Sauce

Experience the true taste of Italian cuisine with Basil Pizza Sauce. Crafted with the finest basil, this sauce is a key ingredient in authentic Italian pizza recipes. Elevate your pizza to new heights by adding the bright aroma of tomato and basil. For an extra burst of flavor, consider adding some vegetables or mushrooms. Indulge in the timeless flavors of Italy with Basil Pizza Sauce.

Alfredo Pizza Sauce

Discover the perfect balance of buttery, creamy flavor, and tantalizing spices with Alfredo Pizza Sauce. Indulge in a symphony of cheeses that will mesmerize your taste buds. This delectable sauce pairs harmoniously with aromatic ingredients like olives, processed meat, steak, mushrooms, bacon, roasted peppers, and artichoke hearts. Elevate your pizza experience with the richness of Alfredo.

BBQ Pizza Sauce

Break away from tradition and discover the mouthwatering combination of tangy BBQ sauce and your favorite toppings. Whether you choose pineapple for a burst of sweetness, bacon for an indulgent crunch, or chicken and ham for a savory twist, BBQ Pizza Sauce will take your taste buds on a one-of-a-kind culinary adventure. Don’t miss out on this unique and delicious twist on a classic favorite. Grab a slice and savor the flavors today.

Pepper Pizza Sauce

Experience the delicious heat of pepper-infused pizza sauce, featuring a medley of red pepper, black pepper, roasted red pepper, and cayenne pepper.

But that’s not all – customize your pizza with an array of mouthwatering toppings. From mushrooms to steak and chicken, add your favorite flavors to create the perfect pizza masterpiece.

Elevate your pizza game with Pepper Pizza Sauce – the ultimate choice for pepper lovers and pizza enthusiasts alike.


All of these store-bought pizza sauce products offer a variety of flavors, textures, and ingredients to please any pizza eater. Any one of these nine options can help amateur chefs take their homemade pizzas to the next level quickly and easily. Consumer preference is always key when it comes to finding the best store-bought pizza sauces so be sure to experiment with different flavors and brands until you find what works for you.

Plus, just like any accompaniment to your favorite dish, a little experimenting can lead to big rewards! So don’t be afraid to spend some time curating the perfect sauce-pizza combination – it will pay off in the end when you taste that soul-warming bite of cheesy deliciousness!

Thanks for reading our article about the Best store-bought pizza sauce. If you want to know more information, visit our website here.

Read more:

Pizza Sauce Vs Marinara

3 Ways to Make Pizza Sauce – wikiHow Life

3 Ways to Make Easy Pizza – wikiHow

Pizza – Wikipedia

Where did pizza originate?

A Slice of History: Pizza in America

Leave a Reply