Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews | Find the Best Oven for You 

Is it time to upgrade your pizza oven? Find out which models are the highest rated according to consumer reports pizza ovens so you can get the best value for money!

Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

Looking for the ultimate homemade pizza experience? Forget delivery, I tested portable pizza ovens from four top brands BakerStone, Gyber, Le Peppe, and Ooni to find out which one cooks the best pies.

Imagine having delicious wood-fired pizza at your fingertips, right in your backyard. With tabletop outdoor pizza ovens, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza with your favorite toppings anytime you want. These versatile appliances use wood, charcoal, or propane to provide the perfect cooking environment.

While outdoor pizza ovens are not new, there’s a recent surge in affordable options that are designed to be used on tabletops. The appeal remains the same – reaching temperatures of over 700°F, similar to professional pizzerias. This is something you just can’t achieve with your regular home oven or most grills. Plus, with wood and charcoal-burning ovens, you get that distinctive smoky flavor that’s impossible to replicate indoors.

As a culinary school grad and former chef, I’ve always been on a quest for the perfect pizza. These outdoor pizza ovens piqued my interest, and I decided to put them to the test. After purchasing four popular models, I set out to see if they could truly deliver the same quality as my favorite pizzerias.

Get ready to discover the best portable pizza oven for your backyard pizza nights with Consumer Reports pizza ovens.

BakerStone Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

BakerStone 9152403 Portable Gas Pizza Oven

Introducing the BakerStone 9152403 Portable Gas Pizza Oven – the ultimate addition to your outdoor adventures. This oven allows you to effortlessly bake artisan pizzas in less than two minutes, delivering that mouthwatering woodfired taste anywhere you go! No permanent installation is required.

With a powerful 25,000 BTU burner system, this oven reaches temperatures over 800˚F, guaranteeing steakhouse-quality meats, vegetables, and fish every time.

The lightweight and portable design of the oven box, complete with folding legs and a regulator, makes it easy to pack up and take with you.

To enhance your cooking experience, optional accessories such as a full griddle, grill grates, or a 1/2 griddle 1/2 grill combo are available (not included).

And don’t worry about fuel – the BakerStone 9152403 only requires a 20 lbs LP gas cylinder (not included).

Don’t let the kitchen hold you back, bring your pizza-making skills on the road with the BakerStone 9152403 Portable Gas Pizza Oven! Get yours today!


  • Bake artisan-quality pizzas in less than 2 minutes.
  • The powerful 25,000 BTU burner system heats up to a sizzling 800°F.
  • Easily transport and clean with its removable oven feature.
  • Enhance your cooking experience with our optional accessories.


  • Portability: Take your pizza oven on the go for picnics and outdoor gatherings.
  • Easy Assembly: Set up the Baker Stone pizza oven effortlessly and get cooking in no time.
  • Even Heating: Enjoy perfectly cooked pizzas with bubbling toppings, thanks to the oven’s consistent heat distribution.
  • Quick Cooking Time: Get delicious, crispy pizzas in a flash, thanks to the oven’s rapid heating capabilities.
  • Affordable: Enjoy all the benefits of a high-quality pizza oven at a wallet-friendly price.


  • Limited interior space
  • Not ideal for 14″ pizzas due to low height and difficulty in maneuvering
  • Best suited for 11-12″ pizzas

GYBER Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

GYBER Fremont Outdoor Pizza Oven Portable 

GYBER Fremont Outdoor Pizza Oven Portable 

Introducing the GYBER Fremont Outdoor Pizza Oven Portable – the must-have backyard oven for delicious wood-fired pizza with smoky flavor perfection! Whether you’re tailgating, camping, or simply enjoying a day at the park, you can bring the Fremont with you wherever you go.

This portable outdoor oven is constructed with lightweight materials, so you can easily transport it to any outdoor destination. Plus, with the special wood-fired flavor, your delicious pizzas will get that unique smoky taste and aroma you know and love!

Take your outdoor cooking to the next level with the Fremont Outdoor Pizza Oven Portable. Enjoy restaurant-quality results with its high-temperature capability of up to 900 ℉/ 482 ℃ and cook your pizzas to perfection in just 3-4 minutes. With the built-in thermometer, you can easily monitor and adjust the temperature to get perfect results each time. Plus, you’ll love the included pizza stone, pizza peel, and ash shovel, so you can easily prepare your pizzas and clean up with ease.

Whether you’re a beginner or a pro chef, the GYBER Fremont Outdoor Pizza Oven Portable is the perfect outdoor companion with its convenience, portability, and delicious wood-fired flavor. Get yours today and experience the difference of smoky wood-fired cooking with ease and convenience!


  • High temperature and fast cooking to save time
  • Versatile with multiple uses and included accessories
  • Highly convenient design, lightweight and portable
  • The special taste of wood-fired smokiness from hardwood pellets
  • High-temperature capability up to 900℉/482℃
  • Easy clean with detachable components


  • Affordability: This product is cheap, making it a cost-effective option for all.
  • Ease of Use: Lighting this product is as simple as lighting any other fire, making it accessible to everyone. If you can light a campfire, you can easily light this product.
  • Comprehensive Package: The product comes with everything you need, including the peel which is often charged extra by other companies.
  • Built-in Thermometer: With a built-in thermometer, you can ensure that the product reaches and maintains the ideal temperature for cooking.
  • Convenient Carry Handle: The product is equipped with a practical carrying handle for easy transportation.
  • Durability: The firebox is thick and heavy, guaranteeing long-lasting and reliable performance.


  • Unstable door: The door doesn’t stay in place even when the oven is tilted back, requiring the use of a brick as a makeshift solution.
  • Slow pizza stone heating: The pizza stone takes longer than the recommended 10-15 minutes to reach the desired cooking temperature, requiring additional waiting time.
  • Lacking insulation: Due to insufficient insulation, the oven requires extra pellets and/or wood chips and needs to be reheated between pizzas.
  • Inadequate directions: The provided instructions are not clear or helpful.

 GYBER Mateo Outdoor Gas Pizza Oven

 GYBER Mateo Outdoor Gas Pizza Oven

Looking to bring the taste of restaurant-style pizzas to your backyard? GYBER Mateo Outdoor Gas Pizza Oven is here to make your pizza dreams come true! This 13″ Portable Rotatable Propane Stainless Steel Pizza Grill is the perfect outdoor pizza maker for the entire family. Customize the pizza to each person’s taste by rotating the bottom rack to evenly bake and prevent burning. Designed for fast and easy cooking, it preheats in just 8-12 minutes, with a cook time of only 90 seconds!

The pizza oven and accessories come with a 13-inch round cordierite pizza stone that can handle extremely high temperatures (up to 2200℉). Not only does this pizza stone ensure delicious, perfectly cooked pizzas, but it also helps to remove excess moisture, creating a delicious, fluffy crust with a moist and delicious inside.

Setting it up and getting it running is straightforward. Hassle-free installation and no tools required! Plus, it comes with a 1.2 meter-long gas pipe (5/8-18UNF gas outlet thread) for a quick and easy way to cook a fresh or frozen pizza.

Bring the unique flavor of homemade pizzas to your backyard with GYBER Mateo Outdoor Gas Pizza Oven! Perfect for family gatherings, outdoor cookouts, or small gatherings, this pizza oven is sure to please! Try it today and experience the deliciousness for yourself!


  • Cook delicious pizzas in just minutes
  • Portable and lightweight design for outdoor use
  • Rotatable device design ensures even baking
  • Easily transportable and installable
  • Cook multiple types of food


  • Easy assembly: It can be set up in just 15 minutes after unboxing.
  • Portable: Take it with you wherever you go.
  • Versatile: Not just for pizza, you can cook other dishes too.
  • Perfect gift: Ideal for BBQ pizza lovers and campers who love experimenting with recipes.
  • Even baking: The bottom rack can be easily rotated to ensure your food is cooked evenly and avoid burning.
  • High-quality construction: Made with food-grade stainless steel for efficient cooking, with a reflective inner shell and heat insulation.


  • You need to rotate the handle with BBQ gloves to avoid getting burned.
  • Use a heat-resistant and sturdy table for setting up the pizza oven.

GYBER Kenya Portable 22″ Outdoor Pizza Oven

GYBER Kenya Portable 22" Outdoor Pizza Oven

Create incredible culinary experiences with the GYBER Kenya Portable 22″ Outdoor Pizza Oven! This top-of-the-line stainless steel and wood-fired pizza maker is the perfect addition to any backyard. 

Its large size and wood and charcoal-powered heating method make it easy to bake multiple pizzas and meats simultaneously, giving you precise temperature control and a quick 2-minute baking time to enjoy perfectly cooked pizza in no time. 

With its sleek modern design, our GYBER Kenya Portable 22″ Outdoor Pizza Oven will be the envy of your family and friends. Whether you’re planning a party or a family get-together, there’s no better way to bring people together around delicious pizzas than with the GYBER Kenya Portable 22″ Outdoor Pizza Oven!


  • Quick 2-minute cooking time
  • Foldable side tables for easy storage
  • Thermometer and glass window for monitoring progress
  • Offers plenty of room for multiple pizzas and other dishes.
  • A thermometer and a glass window front door for effortless monitoring


  • Perfect functionality.
  • Spacious enough to fit a 20’’ pizza.
  • Easy assembly with clear installation instructions.
  • Uses charcoal for a tastier pizza compared to a regular oven.
  • Quick preheating for faster cooking.


  •  Quite bulky
  •  A little expensive, but worth it

Le Peppe Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

Le Peppe Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

Experience the pinnacle of wood-fired cooking with the Le Peppe Portable Wood-Fired Pizza Oven! Crafted with both the passionate hobbyist and culinary professional in mind, this sleek and stylish oven comes packed with features designed to help you cook to perfection every time. With the capacity to reach cooking temperatures of up to 900°F, you can enjoy the freedom to experiment with different flavors and techniques when cooking up everything from savory pizzas to roasted veggies, bread, and more.

Designed with convenience in mind, the Le Peppe is equipped with an easy-to-load firebox, allowing you to choose between power sources to achieve the perfect heat intensity for every dish. Whether you’re shooting for a gentle simmer or an intense heat, Le Peppe has you covered. The high-flow downdraft system ensures efficient air circulation, developing the ideal temperatures rapidly and consistently. Plus, the oven door is equipped with a peephole so you can monitor your dishes without releasing the heat.

So, take your wood-fired dishes to the next level with Le Peppe! With its stylish design, incredible features, and ultimate versatility, this oven gives you the freedom to explore and perfect your culinary creations. Unlock the flavors of wood-fired cooking with Le Peppe!


  • Versatile fuel options: Bake pizza anywhere using wood chunks, chips, pellets, or charcoal.
  • Enhanced heat retention: Thermal guard insulation and R3 Interior technology radiate, reflect, and retain heat, saving fuel and making cooking easier.
  • Improved temperature control: The unique downdraft air induction system ensures precise temperature management.
  • Durable construction: Double-walled steel oven with fire blanket insulation for long-lasting performance.
  • Crispier crusts: Includes an 11mm cordierite baking stone for improved heat retention and perfectly crisp crusts.
  • Compact size: Measuring 31.5″ L x 16″ W x 33″ H, this oven is designed to fit in any space.


  • Easy to assemble
  • Makes delicious pizza
  • Portable, can be taken anywhere
  • Unbelievably easy to use and at a great price
  • Quick cooking time
  • Well built
  • Comes with a bag and peel
  • The oven heats up fast


  • The compact tray requires frequent pellet and wood refills, but it’s worth it!
  • Mastering the art of using it may take some time, but don’t throw in the towel just yet!

Ooni Consumer Reports Pizza Ovens Reviews

Ooni Koda Gas Pizza Oven

Ooni Koda 12 Gas Pizza Oven

Ooni Koda 12 Gas Pizza Oven

Ooni Koda 16 Gas Pizza Oven

Ooni Koda 16 Gas Pizza Oven

Ooni Koda 16 Gas Pizza Oven

Introducing the Ooni Koda Gas Pizza Oven – the ultimate oven for pizza lovers. Our Koda 12 and Koda 16 models offer fabulous pizzas every time. Experience the joy of reaching 500°C in under 15 and 20 minutes, respectively. The pizza stone baking board ensures Neapolitan-style pizzas are ready in just 60 seconds.

Cooking has never been easier with this countertop oven. With instant gas ignition, you can effortlessly create delicious pizzas for your loved ones. Explore the possibilities by using our cast iron cooking accessories to roast meat, fish, or veggies.

Join our global community of Ooni pizza oven enthusiasts. Our ovens have delighted backyard and outdoor kitchens in over 50 countries. The powder-coated carbon steel shell provides unparalleled heat retention, making indoor and outdoor grilling more efficient than ever.

Don’t miss out on this unforgettable experience with the Ooni Koda Gas Pizza Oven.


  • Portable and easily stored.
  • Cook your pizza in only 60 seconds.
  • Ignite to 950°F in no time: Koda 12 in under 15 minutes, Koda 16 in under 20 minutes.
  • Convenient foldable legs for space-saving.
  • Weather-resistant exterior for all conditions.
  • Stay safe with ceramic fiber insulation that keeps the exterior cool to the touch.
  • Automatic gas flow cut-off if the flame goes out.
  • Multi-functional: bake, roast, grill, and sear.


  • Quick and hassle-free setup
  • Mouthwatering pizzas guaranteed
  • Effortless and speedy cooking experience
  • Easy peasy propane hook-up
  • Ready to use out of the box
  • Top-notch quality
  • Perfect for freezing temperatures


  • The Ooni 12 has a melting plastic knob in high temperatures, but the Ooni 16 has a heat-resistant side knob.
  • Avoid burning by regularly rotating and monitoring your pizza in this high-temperature oven.

Expert Tips for Perfect Pizza with the Ooni Fyra Pizza Oven:

– Opt for a gas grill with a 15lb propane tank for optimal results.

– Use a laser pointer thermometer to track the temperature of your pizza stone.

– Use a rolling pin for a flat and even crust. Thinner edges lead to optimal results.

– Avoid making a pizza too large for your oven.

– Position the pizza near the front of the oven to prevent burning.

– Cook your pizza to perfection by being vigilant and turning it as needed.

– Maximize your pizza-making potential by turning up the flame after removing your finished pizza.

– Invest in the Ooni carry cover for ultimate convenience and easy transport of the oven.

Ooni Fyra 12 Wood-Fired Outdoor Pizza Oven

Ooni Fyra 12 Wood Fired Outdoor Pizza Oven

Introducing the Ooni Fyra 12 Wood-Fired Outdoor Pizza Oven – the game-changer for pizza lovers! Now you can make your perfect pies in a fraction of the time. This oven is not only fast and efficient, but it also boasts a world-class design and maximum portability.

With the Ooni Fyra, you can reach soaring temperatures up to 500 degrees Celsius, twice as hot as most home ovens. This means your pizzas cook quickly, evenly, and with superior flavor. Plus, our patented pellet hopper allows for effortless cooking.

But that’s not all – this incredibly lightweight device weighs only 10kg, making it perfect for those on the go. Its powder-coated carbon steel shell ensures maximum heat retention while minimizing energy waste. And with its foldable legs, you can bring your Ooni Fyra anywhere you go.

Experience phenomenal wood-fired cooking wherever you are. Simply assemble your pizza ingredients, fire up the Fyra, and in just 60 seconds, you’ll have the perfect pizza. Join the outdoor pizza party with the Ooni Fyra!


  • Cooks authentic wood-fired pizza in under a minute
  • Lightweight at only 10kg for convenient transportation and storage
  • Effortlessly cooks with auto-feed hardwood pellets
  • Achieves temperatures of 500°C for perfectly stone-baked pizza in just 60 seconds
  • Heats up faster than traditional methods
  • Provides superior control over cooking temperatures and times


  • Simple assembly and usage
  • Rapid heating and powerful fire for quick pizza making
  • Convenient portability for on-the-go cooking
  • Versatile cooking capabilities – perfect for steaks, chicken wings, tuna, and more
  • Handy door hanging feature for easy access while cooking


  • The flame dampener keeps popping off.
  • The chimney dampened should have better resistance for better control. Partially close the chimney dampener to achieve a balanced flame for perfectly cooked dough without burning it.

Expert Tips for Perfect Pizza with the Ooni Fyra Pizza Oven:

  • Stay attentive – the oven gets scorching hot and cooking is lightning fast.
  • Get creative – try out different flavors with smaller pizzas.
  • Constantly turn the pizza to ensure even heating, as the heat is concentrated at the back.
  • Invest in a long-handled pizza paddle for easy maneuvering and to prevent any burnt edges.
  • Don’t forget the essentials – buy a fire starter and hardwood pellets.
  • Mastering the art of homemade wood-fired pizza may require some practice, but there are plenty of online resources to guide you through the process.

Ooni Karu Outdoor Pizza Oven

Ooni Karu 12 Multi-Fuel Outdoor Pizza Oven

ooni Karu 12 Multi-Fuel Outdoor Pizza Oven

Ooni Karu 16 Multi-Fuel Outdoor Pizza Oven

Ooni Karu 16 Multi-Fuel Outdoor Pizza Oven

Introducing the Ooni Karu Outdoor Pizza Oven, the ultimate pizza oven for enthusiasts. Experience the perfection of restaurant-quality pizzas, cooked to perfection in just 60 seconds. With its multi-fuel capabilities and advanced temperature control, this oven ensures consistent and delicious results every time.

Fire up the Karu with wood or charcoal for a subtle wood-fired taste that is unrivaled. Alternatively, use the Ooni Gas Burner for maximum flexibility in cooking experiences. In just 15 minutes, the oven reaches a scorching 950°F / 500°C, guaranteeing your flame-cooked pizza is ready in seconds.

Not only is the Karu fast, but it’s also reliable. With its insulated oven body and a digital thermometer, you can monitor and maintain the perfect internal temperature for impeccable cooking. The fully insulated carbon steel shell ensures enhanced insulation and weather resistance, while optimized airflow regulates temperature control and fuel efficiency.

Join us on a journey of taste with the Ooni Karu Outdoor Pizza Oven. Upgrade your pizza-making game and savor the flavors of perfection.


  • Cook wood-fired pizza in just 60 seconds
  • Precise temperature control with a mounted digital thermometer
  • Full glass oven door design for easy monitoring
  • Charcoal option for low temperatures
  • Gas option for temperature control
  • Versatile roasting, grilling, and searing capabilities


  • User-friendly: Enjoy hassle-free cooking with this easy-to-use oven.
  • Excellent value: Get impressive quality without breaking the bank.
  • Sleek design: Enhance your outdoor space with this sleek and stylish unit.
  • Impeccable craftsmanship: Experience the attention-to-detail with no unfinished surfaces or raw edges.
  • Efficient insulation: Keep the heat in and cold weather out for consistent cooking results.
  • Quick heating: Start enjoying delicious pizza in no time, even on chilly days.


  • Uneven baking: The oven doesn’t bake pizza thoroughly from the bottom, resulting in one side being slightly burnt and the other side not being cooked through.
  • Inconvenience workaround: To ensure even baking, the dough needs to be flipped inside the oven and then topped with pizza ingredients before being inserted back into the oven.

Expert Tips for Perfect Pizza with the Ooni Karu Outdoor Pizza Oven:

  • Turn your pizza every 25 seconds for a perfect result in just a minute and a half.
  • Save energy by using wood fuel.
  • Invest in a quality grill brush to keep your oven clean and maintain flavor.
  • Use a high temp glove or tongs for easy cooking adjustments.
  • Manage your wood supply to ensure the right fuel amount.
  • Follow these expert tips for delicious wood-fired pizza every time.

What to look for when buying a pizza oven?

When it comes to buying a pizza oven, there are several factors to consider. Here’s a brief overview of what you should look for in the perfect pizza oven: 

  • Ease of use: Choose an oven that is easy to assemble and has intuitive controls. Avoid any intricate assembly or complex settings that will add extra time and hassle. 
  • Temperature control: Look for an oven that has adjustable temperature settings so you can customize the cooking process to your preferences.
  • Cooking time: Consider how long it takes for the oven to heat up and how long it takes to cook a pizza or other food item. 
  • Quality of materials: Look for an oven with high-quality materials such as carbon steel or stainless steel that are built to last. 
  • Mobility: If you plan on moving your oven, look for a lightweight model with convenient features like wheels and handles. 
  • Versatility: Choose an oven that is versatile enough to cook different types of food items beyond pizza, such as meat, vegetables, fish, etc. 
  • Safety features: Choose an oven that has built-in safety features, such as heat-resistant handles, flame-retardant materials, and thermal shock protection. 

By taking the time to review all of these factors, you can be sure to find the perfect pizza oven for your needs. With the right product in hand, you’ll be able to experience delicious wood-fired pizza in the comfort of your own home. Bon Appetite! 

Keep in mind that safety is always paramount when dealing with high temperatures or open flames and you should follow all manufacturer recommendations for proper installation and use. Additionally, it’s a good idea to practice safe handling techniques such as wearing heat-resistant gloves, using long-handled utensils, and never leaving the oven unattended. 

When you’re ready to cook, take the time to thoroughly preheat your pizza oven before you start making pizzas. Preheating will ensure that all of the ingredients are cooked evenly for the best results. Depending on what type of fuel you are using, it can take up to 45 minutes for the oven to reach the optimal temperature for cooking.

Finally, remember to clean your pizza oven regularly with a grill brush or wire brush to keep it in top condition and preserve the flavor of your food. With proper care and maintenance, you can enjoy delicious wood-fired pizzas from the comfort of your own home for years to come! 


Is Ooni made in China?

Ooni, the innovative outdoor pizza oven company, is based in Edinburgh, Scotland. While the ovens are thoughtfully designed in Scotland, they are manufactured in China. Ooni proudly introduced the world to the first-ever portable wood-pellet-fired pizza oven back in 2012.

What is the maximum temperature of the Karu pizza oven?

The Karu can reach temperatures up to a maximum of 950°F/500°C. 

Which is better: a wood-fired or gas pizza oven?

When it comes to choosing between these two options, it ultimately depends on what you value most in your cooking experience.

If convenience, cleanliness, and simplicity are important to you, then a gas oven is the way to go.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for that irresistible smoky and authentic flavor in your pizzas, and want to create a stunning centerpiece for your party, then a wood-fired pizza oven is the perfect choice.

Make the right decision based on your preferences and enjoy the ultimate pizza experience!

Why should you invest in a wood-fired pizza oven?

Discover the secret to perfectly cooked Neapolitan pizza in just two minutes! With temperatures reaching a scorching 450°C (800°F), wood-fired ovens are your shortcut to authentic, mouthwatering pizza. Say goodbye to limitations with electric ovens, which can’t handle temperatures above 250°C (450°F). Elevate your pizza game and embrace the unmatched flavor and speed of a wood-fired pizza oven.


After delving into the Consumer Reports reviews of four different pizza ovens, it is evident that each one holds its own set of unique advantages and disadvantages. 

BakerStone has high ratings for affordability and user-friendliness while Gyber’s portability makes it a good option for camping and tailgates. 

Le Peppe is a great choice for those with a more classic taste in design as well as those who enjoy brick-oven-style cooking. 

Lastly, Ooni’s versatility, including its use on both gas grills and open-flame fuel sources, makes it an ideal pizza oven for anyone looking to try unique flavors. 

All in all, the best pizza oven will depend on which features are most important to the individual consumer. 

However, any of these four pizza ovens recommended by Consumer Reports can provide excellent results when used properly!

Thanks for reading our article. If you want to know more information, visit our website here.

Read more:

What Oven Temperature for Pizza?

How to Make Pizza at Home That’s Better Than Takeout

The Right Oven Temperature for Homemade Pizza

Homemade Pizza & Pizza Dough


Leave a Reply