Big City Pizza Review: Is It Good?

Big City Pizza

Big City Pizza

If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, you have to try Big City Pizza downtown. After a long day of work, there’s nothing like kicking back with a delicious slice of pizza and watching the hustle and bustle of city life unfold right outside your window. 

Whether this is your go-to spot for lunch or dinner, or if it’s just a place you like to check out every once in a while, it has got something for everyone. From classic styles pies to vegetarian options, from gluten-free to deep-dish, there’s something on the menu that will tantalize even the pickiest eaters. 

I had the pleasure of trying out this popular spot recently, and it exceeded all my expectations — from the incredible flavor combinations available on their menu to their cozy yet contemporary vibe, Big City Pizza is worth checking out!

About Big City Pizza

Big City Pizza is a local favorite located in the heart of downtown. They have been serving up the delicious, handmade pizza since 2014 and they pride themselves on using only premium ingredients to ensure an unforgettable experience for their customers. All of their pies are made with fresh-baked dough from scratch and topped with flavorful sauces made in-house. They also offer salads, sandwiches, wings, desserts, and more — so you can make a meal out of it! Additionally, they have an impressive selection of beer and wines. 

The atmosphere at the restaurant is worth mentioning too — the décor is simple yet stylish, making this spot feel like an upscale pizzeria without the hefty price tag. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or dinner, or a place to hang out and watch the game, it is sure to be your go-to spot for weekday eats. 

If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, this city is worth checking out! With their delicious pies, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff, it’s no wonder this local favorite has become one of downtown’s most popular spots.


Since its inception in 2014 by Johnny Hunt in Nicholasville, this concept has grown to include seven thriving locations, including the Chinoe Shopping Center in Lexington. In just 15 short months, the restaurant group has launched three 5 stores, extending its reach to Danville and Richmond. The talented team behind this culinary success story includes a founding member, Johnny Hunt, as well as operating partners Curtis Gorden and Joey Davis, who joined the group at its Hamburg location. Join us as we continue to elevate the dining experience in Kentucky and beyond.

Big City Pizza’s Hamburg location is now open for both counter service and delivery, seven days a week. Enjoy your meal in our spacious dining room equipped with four large-screen TVs, a shuffleboard, and an arcade game area. Al fresco dining is also available.

Join us for the same menu items available at all of our locations, featuring classic New York and Chicago-style pizzas, calzones, salads, and delectable desserts featuring ice cream from Richmond-based Mad Scoop.

Big City Pizza Menu


Navy Pier Garlic Knots

Freshly baked dough immersed in a flavorful mixture of garlic butter and Italian seasoning then topped off with a generous sprinkle of premium parmesan cheese. Every bite is an explosion of savory flavors that will leave you wanting more. Served alongside a classic, zesty marinara sauce, it’s a perfect appetizer to share with friends and family. Try it now and experience a burst of deliciousness in every knot.

Statue of Liberty Cheesesticks

Indulge in scrumptious homemade dough enveloping a cheesy filling and paired with flavorful marinara – a divine rendition of the iconic American symbol, the Statue of Liberty. Try savory cheese sticks for a taste of pure satisfaction.

Buffalo, NY Wings

Satisfy your cravings with Buffalo, NY’s finest wings! Enjoy eight perfectly cooked wings smothered in your preferred sauce – options include garlic parm, hot, mild, bbq, bourbon glaze, mango jalapeño, and sweet Thai chili – accompanied with a side of ranch or blue cheese dressing for the ultimate taste experience.

Chi-Town Meatballs

A delectable dish featuring four succulent meatballs smothered in a rich marinara sauce and topped with a generous sprinkle of cheese. Savor the flavors of this exceptional menu item that promises to tantalize your taste buds. Don’t miss out on this irresistible culinary delight.

Mac-n-Cheese Wedges

Satisfy your cravings with irresistible Mac-n-Cheese Wedges, featuring seven pieces of scrumptious goodness. Bite into a crispy exterior to reveal the creamy and comforting mac-n-cheese inside. Don’t miss out on this delicious treat.

Pretzel Knots with Beer Cheese

Indulge in scrumptious Pretzel Knots alongside a variety of delectable beer cheese choices! Made fresh and baked to perfection, gourmet pretzel knots are paired with your choice of flavorful cheese dips – featuring Pepper Jack, White Cheddar, Mild, and Jalapeno varieties. Satisfy your cravings and enjoy the ultimate snacking experience with this delectable treat.

Bone-In Wings


Big City House Salad

Packed with crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, savory bacon, and rich cheese. Customize the flavors with your choice of dressing- ranch, blue cheese, Italian, Caesar, honey mustard, or balsamic vinaigrette. A perfect blend of fresh ingredients and robust flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.

Antipasto Salad

Featuring crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, zesty black olives, tangy banana peppers, savory pepperoni, succulent ham, delectable cheese, and flavorful Italian dressing. Savor the irresistible blend of flavors, textures, and aromas in every bite of this impeccably crafted dish. Perfect for a satisfyingly wholesome and delicious meal, Antipasto Salad is truly a feast for the senses.

Caesar Salad

Crafted with crispy romaine lettuce, freshly grated Parmesan cheese, crispy croutons, and a zesty Caesar dressing. A perfect balance of flavor and texture in every bite.


Wrigley Field Cheesesteak

A delicious sandwich consisting of thinly sliced beef, onions, green peppers, and cheese on a toasted bun. Satisfy your cravings with this mouth-watering option that’s sure to hit the spot. Perfect for lunch or a snack while cheering on your favorite team.

Empire State Sausage Sub

A delectable sandwich that boasts succulent sausage, onions, green peppers, and cheese between two slices of perfectly toasted buns. This mouth-watering creation is sure to become your new favorite go-to snack. Try it now and satisfy your taste buds with the goodness of this expertly-crafted sandwich.

Sears Tower Meatball Sub

A delectable combination of succulent meatballs, tangy marinara sauce, and gooey cheese, nestled between two slices of crispy, toasted bun. Get your taste buds ready for a collision of flavors and textures that will leave you craving more of this irresistible sandwich. Savor each bite as the savory meatballs mingle with the zesty marinara and savory cheese in perfect harmony. Enjoy this mouthwatering sandwich that’s guaranteed to satisfy your hunger and taste buds.

Manhattan-style Ham & Cheese Melt

A timeless combination of savory ham and melting cheese, all nestled within a perfectly toasted bun. Simply satisfying and delicious.

Central Park Veggie Sub 

A delectable sandwich bursting with a medley of savory flavors. Savor the goodness of sautéed mushrooms, onions, green peppers, artichokes, and melted cheese, all tucked into a perfectly toasted bun. A vegetarian delight that will tantalize your taste buds!

Union Station Chicken Parm

A delectable grilled chicken sandwich, smothered in savory parmesan cheese and tangy marinara, all served on a crisp toasted bun. Don’t miss out on this mouth-watering meal!

Little Italy Sub

A mouth-watering combination of pepperoni, sausage, ham, cheese, and Italian dressing, served on a toasted bun. Satisfy your craving for the perfect sandwich with this delicious option.

Fifth Ave Heartache

Presenting Fifth Ave Heartache, the perfect sandwich for your cravings! Enjoy succulent grilled chicken, crispy bacon, luscious cheese, and tangy buffalo sauce all nestled within a toasted bun, topped off with the creamy goodness of ranch dressing. One bite and you’ll be transported to sandwich heaven.


Big Apple Baked Ziti

Delight in the savory flavors of Big Apple Baked Ziti, a classic Italian casserole featuring ziti pasta, perfectly seasoned Italian sausage, rich marinara sauce, and mouthwatering cheese. Each bite will transport your taste buds to the heart of Italy, leaving you craving more. Try the signature dish today and experience a culinary journey you won’t soon forget.

Ellis Island Chicken Alfredo 

Succulent chicken pieces and penne noodles smothered in velvety alfredo sauce and topped with rich cheese. A dish that will leave you craving more.

Windy City Spaghetti and Meatballs

A savory Italian classic featuring baked spaghetti smothered in rich marinara sauce and accompanied by perfectly seasoned meatballs. Satisfy your cravings and treat yourself to a hearty meal unlike any other.

Pullman Calzone

A mouth-watering, homemade dough that is stuffed with your choice of marinara or ricotta, with the additional option of adding two toppings to make it a unique specialty for only an extra $2.00. Satisfy your cravings with this must-try calzone.



Looking for delicious pizza with a variety of crust options? The menu has got you covered. Choose from classic New York Hand Tossed, crispy Thin, and Crispy, or flavorful Gluten-Free crust in sizes ranging from 10 inches to 16 inches. In addition, we offer a savory Pan option in both 12-inch and 14-inch sizes, as well as a unique Cauliflower Crust 10 inch and Crust-less Pizza Bowl featuring signature house-made sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, and up to 5 toppings. Don’t settle for plain pizza when you can enjoy a customizable and mouth-watering experience at the restaurant.


Looking for a pizza that can satisfy your cravings? Delicious pizza toppings are perfect for any taste buds! With pepperoni, meatball, Italian sausage, pork sausage, bacon, ham, beef, and grilled chicken, cup pepperoni, deli slice pepperoni, Big City Pizza has got you covered with the best ingredients.

Are you a fan of veggies? Pizza toppings include onion, green pepper, mushroom, black olive, green olive, tomato, garlic, spinach, and jalapeno, banana pepper. Are you in the mood for something unique? Try our artichokes, pineapples, and ricotta cheese, cheddar cheese, basil, or add some anchovies for a little zing. Whether you prefer cheddar cheese or basil, we’ve got your perfect topping combination.

With amazing toppings, you can create your signature pizza or choose from a selection of specialty pizzas. Don’t settle for bland pizza. Order now and treat yourself to delicious toppings!

The Bronx

Indulge in a mouth-watering pizza that packs a punch of flavor with our Bronx-style creation. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, and bacon, every bite of this delectable delight is a combination of savory meats that will satisfy your cravings.

The Great Lakes

Indulge in a delicious pizza topped with an assortment of fresh ingredients, including savory mushroom, onion, green pepper, ripened tomato, and bold black olive.

The West Town

Indulge in a mouth-watering pizza drizzled with fiery buffalo sauce, succulent grilled chicken, and a creamy ranch base at The West Town. Satisfy your taste buds with the perfect blend of spicy and savory flavors in every bite. Come and experience a delectable culinary journey that will leave you craving for more.

The SOHO pizza

Featuring a savory ricotta base topped with flavorful onion, garlic, mushroom, and artichoke. Satisfy your cravings with this delectable pizza creation.

The Coney Island

It’s a perfect combination of ham, pineapple, garlic, and bacon. Satisfy your cravings and indulge in its flavorful goodness. Join us for a pizza feast and treat yourself to a slice of heaven.

The Midway

The mouth-watering pizza is topped with a tangy bbq base, succulent grilled chicken, flavorful onion, and melted cheddar cheese. Don’t miss out on this heavenly pie, crafted especially for pizza aficionados like you.

The Deluxe

A mouth-watering pizza featuring a perfect combination of pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, and mushroom. Satisfy your pizza cravings with this delicious and classic option that packs a flavorful punch.

The Hudson

Indulge in The Hudson pizza topped with a mouthwatering combination of pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, black olive, and bacon. Satisfy your cravings for a delicious and hearty meal with this irresistible pizza.

The Tipsy Chicken

Looking for a new addition to your pizza collection? Try The Tipsy Chicken! Enjoy a mouth-watering pie with a delectable pepper jack beer cheese base, grilled chicken, and bacon, topped off with an optional bourbon glaze. Treat yourself to something special and indulge in a delicious pizza experience.

Chicken Bacon Ranch 

This delectable treat features a delicious ranch base, grilled chicken, and crispy bacon – all guaranteed to satisfy your cravings. Don’t miss out on the perfect blend of meaty and cheesy goodness. Order now to savor every bite of this mouth-watering delight.

3 Point Pep

Savor the scrumptious flavors of our 3 Point Pep pizza. Made with not one or two, but three layers of varied-style pepperoni – it’s the perfect pizza experience!

3 Cheese Mac & Cheese Pizza

The cheesy goodness of traditional macaroni and cheese is peppered with rich mozzarella and parmesan cheese, delivering a taste explosion that will leave you wanting more. Order now and experience the ultimate pizza indulgence.

Big Bambino

Looking for a pizza that’s larger than life? Look no further than Big Bambino’s ginormous 28-inch pizza. Satisfy your cravings with this massive pie, perfect for feeding a crowd or indulging in a solo pizza party. Bite into the delicious flavors of our traditional crust and fresh toppings, all in one unforgettable meal. Don’t settle for an average pizza, go Big Bambino.

Stuffed Pizza 

A mouthwatering delight that comes in a 12-inch size. Although it takes a bit longer to bake, we promise that the wait will be worth it. Treat yourself to the best and savor every bite.


Giant Brownie 

A treat big enough to share yet small enough to devour all on your own. Experience pure decadence in every bite and satisfy your chocolate cravings. Don’t miss out on this delicious dessert.

Cinna Knots

A delectable treat made from a soft dough that’s tied in knots and baked to perfection. These heavenly delights are then generously coated with cinnamon and topped off with a mouth-watering icing drizzle. Indulge in the perfect combination of sweet and savory flavors with every bite.

Chocolate Covered Cannoli 

Crispy pastry shells filled with rich chocolate chips and dipped in luxurious chocolate. Satisfy your sweet tooth with this irresistible treat.

Huge Cookie

A generously sized and freshly baked chocolate chip cookie, perfectly warm and gooey, ideal for sharing amongst friends and loved ones. Indulge in the ultimate cookie experience.


Soda + Water


We have 7 locations around the city. Visit our store today and enjoy our delicious pizzas, desserts, and drinks. We’re open 7 days a week for your convenience!

Here are Big City Pizza’s locations:

Lexington ​(Chinoe Road)


1060 Chinoe Road



​114 Williams Road



1560 Hustonville Road



1105 A Kim Kent Drive

Lexington (Hamburg)


2312 Sir Barton Way



​311 W Mount Vernon Street

Mt. Sterling


531 E Main Street

What’s Everyone Saying about BCP?

What’s Customers Like?

Great pizza was prepared promptly.

Big City Pizza’s Chicago Stuffed deep dish pizza is a delicious and authentically made dish, featuring a buttery crust, tangy tomato sauce, plenty of cheese, and my go-to toppings of pepperoni, sausage, and garlic.

A Big City House Salad is a great option for those seeking an indulgent meal, with tomatoes, bacon, and mozzarella cheese as the main ingredients.

The cheese sticks at the restaurant were better than average, and the menu offers a variety of styles of pizza, including Chicago-style stuffed.

The Calzone was the highlight of the visit and everything else we tried was also really good.

They have a freshly-baked cookie that was warm and delicious.

Service, prices, and quality of food combined to make the experience positive and likely to be repeated.

The go-to spot for pizza is reliable with great service and hot, delicious food available for contactless delivery or pick up.

Although the wait was longer than expected, the pizza from this local spot was worth it.

The veggie and meat pizzas at this restaurant were excellent, making it a great choice to visit again.

The restaurant is delivered quickly and has a tasty thin crust, while the restaurant is pleasant and clean.

The tipsy chicken pizza is the best in Kentucky.

This restaurant consistently offers friendly service and freshly-prepared food.

This small, cozy restaurant offers fresh-tasting pizza and friendly service that ensures the customer’s satisfaction.

The pizza, breadsticks, cannoli, and cookies were all delicious and reasonably priced.

BCP is now a top choice for pizza for my family due to its great burgers, cheese sticks, and friendly staff.

This restaurant offers delicious beer cheese, chicken Alfredo, calzones, and wings, along with a variety of bottled beer, although it only carries Pepsi products.

What’s Customers Don’t Like?

The pizza is fine, but it always takes 20-30 mins longer than the estimated time they give you.

The pizza was terrible, with no meat or vegetables and an unpleasant sauce.

The pepperoni pizza was delivered cold and was terrible when reheated, with no response from the establishment.

Ordered a thin veggie pizza but received a thick crust, cold and flavorless one that was delivered late.

Customers regularly experience inaccurate wait times on their website, which can add up to an additional 10-20 minutes of wait time.

The pizza was substandard and greasy, while the pretzel knots were good but accompanied by a stingy amount of Parmesan cheese.

While the pizza was good, this restaurant experience was strange and unorganized, with limited menu options, no plates or fountain drinks, and only one paper plate for a family.


Does Big City Pizza have online ordering?

Yes, BCP has online ordering available through its website. You can also order through the restaurant’s app or by calling one of its locations.

Does BCP deliver?

Yes, BCP offers delivery services to customers within a certain radius of each location. Customers can call ahead or place an online order for delivery.

You can enjoy our delicious pizzas from the comfort of your own home, office, or anywhere you like. Our affordable delivery fee is only $4.50, ensuring that you get your hot and fresh pizza delivered straight to your doorstep. Order now and savor the taste of our mouth-watering pizzas without leaving your location!

Does Big City Pizza offer gluten-free options?

Yes, BCP offers both gluten-free crust and specialty pizzas that are free from gluten. It also offers other menu items that are certified as gluten-free.

Are there vegetarian options at BCP?

Yes, there are several vegetarian options available at BCP, including veggie pizza and salads made with organic and locally-sourced vegetables. Vegetarians can also enjoy the restaurant’s signature beer cheese, which is made without animal products.

Does Big City Pizza offer catering services?

Yes, BCP offers catering services for large parties and events. The restaurant can provide customized menus, delivery services, and setups to accommodate your needs. Catering orders must be placed at least 24 hours in advance to ensure availability.

Does Big City Pizza offer curbside pickup?

Yes, BCP offers curbside pickup at its locations. Customers can place orders online and pick up their orders without leaving their vehicles. Curbside pickup is fast, convenient, and contactless for customers’ safety.

Does BCP have thin-crust pizza?

Yes, BCP offers thin-crust pizza with a variety of toppings. Customers can customize their pizzas with various toppings, including traditional and gourmet selections. Thin-crust pizzas are available in both regular and large sizes.

Does Big City Pizza use fresh ingredients?

BCP only uses the freshest ingredients in its recipes for all of its menu items, so customers can be sure that they’re getting quality food every time. The restaurant sources organic and locally-sourced produce for its salads and other vegetables to ensure the highest level of flavor and nutrition.

What food is served at BCP?

BCP has an expansive menu that includes a selection of pizzas, salads, appetizers, desserts, and drinks. Customers can also enjoy the restaurant’s signature beer cheese dip with pretzel knots or house-made garlic bread for an extra special treat. The menu is designed to please any palate.

What types of payment does Big City Pizza accept?

BCP accepts cash payments as well as credit cards such as Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. Contactless payments including Apple Pay and Google Pay are also accepted at select locations. For online orders, customers can pay via PayPal or Venmo.

Is there a minimum order requirement from BCP?

Yes, there is a minimum order requirement for delivery and curbside pickup orders from BCP. The minimum order amount is $10 before tax. Additional fees may apply for larger orders or special requests.

What types of promotions does Big City Pizza offer?

BCP offers a variety of promotions, including daily specials, weekly discounts, and loyalty rewards programs. Customers can also sign up for the restaurant’s email list to receive exclusive coupons and deals straight to their inboxes. Follow BCP on social media to stay updated on the latest offers.

Is Big City Pizza open on Sunday?

Yes, BCP is open every Sunday from 12 PM to 9 PM, and we offer both delivery and pickup options for your convenience. As our schedule is subject to change, we kindly advise you to revisit our updates to stay in the know.

What time does Big City Pizza at Lexington open?

BCP at Lexington opens daily at 12 PM and closes at 10 PM. Customers can order delivery or place a pickup order any day of the week.

What are the hours for Big City Pizza at Somerset?

Discover the delivery hours for BCP, which is open seven days a week. Fine-tune your plans and mark your calendars to satisfy your cravings! Please keep in mind that these time slots are subject to change, so keep an eye out! Here is their complete delivery schedule:

Monday through Thursday: 11:00 am to 10:00 pm

Friday and Saturday: 11:00 am to 11:00 pm

Sunday: 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm.

Does Big City Pizza have any deals?

Yes, BCP offers daily deals, discounts, and other promotions to its customers. Customers can also sign up for the restaurant’s email list to receive exclusive coupons and offer straight to their inboxes. Follow BCP on social media to stay updated on the latest special offers. Additionally, loyalty rewards programs are available for regular customers who order from the restaurant frequently. These loyalty programs include free items or discounts on large orders.


All in all, the Big City Pizza experience was unique and enjoyable. From the friendly and attentive staff to the impressive range of pizzas available, it’s a great spot for anyone looking for an outstanding Italian feast. The abundance of toppings added that extra flourish to each slice and certainly brought out the flavors in every bite.

If you happen to be in this vibrant city, make sure you drop by Big City Pizza and try out their delicious food. With reasonable prices and good service, I’m sure that you too will enjoy your time here as much as I did. So go ahead and savor the flavors waiting for you at this modern eatery!

If you want to know more information, visit our website here.


Ricotta and Vegetable Stuffed Pizza Pie

Cheesy Stuffed Pizza Pie

What is a stuffed pizza?


Leave a Reply