Discover the best pizza stone for Traeger Grill. Read our review of 9 options and find which one will help make your next pizza night a success!
Best Pizza Stone for Traeger Grills: 9 Options
Craving a crispy, perfectly baked pizza and looking for the right tool to get it? Look no further than the best pizza stone for Traeger grills! When it comes to making delicious pizzas with your Traeger grill, nothing can beat that restaurant-quality texture you get with a high-quality pizza stone.
We’ve rounded up 9 of our top picks – from budget-friendly stones to ultra-premium stones – so you’ll find the perfect fit for scrumptious homemade pies. Read on to discover which one is right for you!
Why Buy a Pizza Stone for Your Traeger Grill?
Enhance your pizza game with these 4 compelling reasons to invest in a pizza stone for your Traeger grill:
Consistent heat distribution: Say goodbye to unevenly cooked pizzas. A pizza stone ensures that heat is evenly spread across the entire surface, preventing burnt spots and delivering a perfectly cooked crust. This is especially important for Traeger grills with potential hot spots and uneven heat distribution.
Irresistibly crispy crust: Harness the high heat of your Traeger grill without the risk of a burnt crust. The pizza stone absorbs and evenly distributes the heat, resulting in a crispy, crunchy crust that rivals the authentic brick oven taste.
The porous surface of the stone also absorbs moisture from the dough, adding to the delectable texture.
Unleash your culinary creativity: A pizza stone isn’t limited to just making pizzas. Expand your grilling repertoire by using it to bake bread, cookies, and even grill vegetables. This versatile tool allows you to explore new culinary horizons and maximize the potential of your Traeger grill.
Effortless cleaning: No one wants to spend valuable grilling time scrubbing their tools. Thankfully, pizza stones are incredibly easy to clean, needing just a quick scrub with a brush or scraper to remove any residue.
With a pizza stone, you can focus on enjoying your delicious creations, knowing that clean-up is a breeze.
Invest in a pizza stone today and elevate your grilling game on your Traeger grill. Capture the perfect pizza experience and unlock a world of culinary possibilities.
List of the Best Pizza Stone for Traeger Grills
Best Pizza Stone for Traeger Grills: 9 Options
HANS GRILL Pizza Stone
Welcome to HANS GRILL, the best pizza stone for Traeger grills in your favorite Italian creations! This stoneware is made from tough, porous cordierite stone and is FDA-safe and heat-resistant.
Whether you’re cooking indoors or outdoors, the pizza pan easily fits in your oven or BBQ to help evenly distribute heat for a delicious finish.
You’ll love the taste and texture of your gourmet pizzas from the grill – the cheese will be wonderfully melted and the crust will be golden-brown and crispy, just like a professional Italian kitchen. Plus, with this pizza stone, you can bake everything from frozen pizza, pies, pastry, and calzone to artisan bread.
HANS GRILL understands the importance of convenience and care for your pizza stone. That’s why this pan is easy to clean with warm water, giving you more time to enjoy your gourmet meals. Whether you’re a master chef or a pizza novice, you’ll love how the stone can elevate the flavor of your Italian delights.
What’s more, HANS GRILL believes that everyone should have access to delicious, wood-fired pizza. That’s why they proudly guarantee that your satisfaction is their number one priority.
If for any reason, the stone doesn’t meet your expectations, contact them and they’ll make sure to give you the best service they can.
Transform your culinary experience with HANS GRILL Pizza Stone and enjoy delicious, restaurant-quality pizzas right from your very own kitchen – or grill.
What do people like?
- Lightweight and portable design for easy handling
- An affordable price point that won’t break the bank
- Rapid heating time for quick and delicious pizzas
- Exceptional durability – this stone is built to last!
- Achieve perfect pizza crust every time with impressive results.
What do people not like?
- Lengthy and energy-intensive preheating process
- The unpleasant aftertaste in the pizza crust, possibly due to the stone
- Difficult to clean due to restrictions on washing with soap and water
- Challenging to store a dirty pizza stone without picking up cooking odors or contaminating clean dishes
Cast Elegance’s Durable Thermal Shock Resistant Thermarite Pizza and Baking Stone
Introducing Cast Elegance’s Durable Thermal Shock Resistant Thermarite Pizza and Baking Stone. Pizzeria-quality pizza at home is now a reality!
This 5/8th-inch thick stoneware pizza stone provides chef-level crispness and ensures the perfect crunchy bite on your pizza crust. Thermarite is an ideal stone material to absorb moisture and transfer easily from the peel to the oven or grill.
Besides pizza, the Cast Elegance Pizza and Baking Stone are also ideal for baking bread, pastries, and other dishes. Its superior durability and heat retention make it safe for both grills and ovens, elevating your culinary craft to a whole new level. Plus, its stone material is 100% food-safe and odorless.
To make sure that you get the most out of the Cast Elegance Pizza and Baking Stone, they’ve included a scraper for cutting and cleaning, as well as a 30-page recipe book filled with delicious ideas to make your kitchen adventures more special.
Clean the stone with a damp cloth after use (no soap or water); it’s also recommended to use parchment paper sheets when using fresh or homemade dough.
The Cast Elegance Pizza and Baking Stone is an essential tool for every culinary artist in the kitchen. Get your hands on this professional-grade pizza stone and become the pizza master you want to be!
What do people like?
- Delivers a perfect pizza crust and crispy bottom every time
- Versatile: works for shrimp and tater tots too
- Durable and superior cooking performance due to its thickness
- Well-packaged for safe delivery
- Includes a scraper for easy cleaning of baked-on spills
- Comes with clear instructions for use and cleaning
What do people not like?
- Stone is heavy and requires both hands to handle when removed from the stove.
- Cooked foods may leave slight stains on the stone, but it’s not a significant concern.
Unicook’s Heavy-Duty Cordierite Pizza Stone
Are you ready to make the perfect pizza? Unicook’s Heavy Duty Cordierite Pizza Stone is crafted with the highest quality material for the perfect pizza time!
Made of all-natural Cordierite and sintered in a 2100°F kiln, you will get the strength, durability, and heat resistance needed to make your pizzas crispy and delicious every time.
What’s even better, this best Pizza Stone for Traeger grills is great for both home use and family gatherings and parties, as it measures 15” x 12” x 0.6” and weighs up to 6.6 lbs for the ultimate pizza-making experience.
And if that wasn’t enough, you also get a multi-purpose scraper, which can be used to cut pastry dough or easily remove any residue from the stone.
You won’t even have a hard time cleaning up since a warm hand wash or a brush will do the trick nicely. And with absolutely no unpleasant odor when heating, you can be sure this Unicook Pizza Stone is the perfect choice for those delicious pizzas!
So don’t wait anymore: get the Heavy Duty Cordierite Pizza Stone and start your amazing pizza experience!
What do people like?
- Consistently delivers perfectly cooked pizza with a crispy crust
- Ideal size for oven rack
- Solid and well-made, with over 1/2 inch thickness
- Highly rated and great price point, with a bonus dough scraper, included.
What do people not like?
- Cleaning can be challenging, but some see it as adding flavor.
- It is prone to staining. However, this does not affect the quality of pizza cooking.
NerdChef’s Steel Stone
Are you a pizza lover looking for the ultimate baking experience? Look no further than NerdChef’s Steel Stone — the high-performance pizza baking stone that will make your pizza night even more delicious!
This amazing stone performs 20x better than ceramic stones and doubles the heat capacity of standard ovens! Not to mention the added benefits of faster bake times and beautiful, perfectly-blistered crusts that get you much closer to the results of a 1000F wood-fired oven.
The pre-seasoned surface also makes it easier to handle with its finger holes. And the solid steel is unbreakable and guaranteed for life, so you know you’re making a secure investment. No need to be afraid of dropping your stone!
Plus, you can use it cold too — just put some ice underneath and it becomes a cold plate. Or use dry ice to make ice cream directly on the surface!
Make the most of your pizza night with NerdChef’s Steel Stone and get the great performance of a 1000F oven right in your home kitchen.
What do people like?
- Solid heavy-duty steel construction for ultimate durability.
- Easy to clean, ensuring hassle-free maintenance.
- Versatile cooking capability – perfect for pizzas, bread, Stromboli, and more.
- Impeccable craftsmanship for a professional-quality cooking experience.
- The exceptionally sturdy design guarantees long-lasting performance.
What do people not like?
- It is extremely heavy and there is a constant fear of dropping it and causing injury.
- It needs to be left in the oven due to its weight, making it difficult to move when needed.
- The pre-heating process is quite time-consuming.
Cuisinart CPS-445 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set
Have you been in constant search of the perfect pizza option that will work flawlessly in your Traeger smoker or other grills? Well, then look no further than the Cuisinart CPS-445 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set!
Whether you are hosting a pizza party or just looking for an amazing new way to enjoy pizza night at home, the Cuisinart CPS-445 is sure to make every pizza an exceptional meal.
This amazing set includes a 13″ pizza stone, folding peel, and pizza cutter, all made from durable and long-lasting materials, such as stainless steel and ceramic.
This best pizza stone for Traeger grills is specially designed with cordierite, which helps retain high temperatures for longer and creates an evenly crisp and tasty crust.
You can even use the stone for other treats such as bagels, toast, waffles, and tortillas. What’s more, it’s super easy to clean and use! Just hand wash it after use and it will be all ready for more pizza fun.
The Cuisinart CPS-445 is the perfect companion to take your pizza game to the next level. It’s reliable and efficient and all at a great price! So why not try it out and let your guests indulge in the perfect crispy pizza crust with every bite? Get it today and start your journey to pizza perfection.
What do people like?
- User-friendly interface
- Effortless cleaning process
- Incredible value for money with excellent quality
- Experience a perfectly crispy crust thanks to its powerful heating performance.
What do people not like?
- No instructions included.
- The pizza stone may stain, although this is a common issue with all pizza stones. However, it can still be cleaned effectively despite slight staining.
Augosta’s Round Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill
Are you looking to upgrade your home cooking game? Augosta’s Round Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill is just the resource you need!
Crafted from 100% FDA-safe Cordierite stone, it’s packed with features that make it as practical as it is reliable. It’s equipped with a non-stick glaze, making it easy to clean. And its excellent heat resistance of up to 1112°F means entertaining at home just got that much easier!
But that’s not all – this best Pizza Stone for Traeger grills is so much more than just a pizza stone! It’s also perfect for bread, cookies, and stuffed calzone. The possibilities are endless! And with the thermal shock resistance of Cordierite, you’re sure to experience evenly distributed heat.
We stand by the quality of our product, which is why we offer a worry-free after-sales service! If you encounter any issues with the product or need any information during use, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Enjoy the ease and convenience of your Augosta Round Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill! Make mealtime fun and stress-free, every time.
What do people like?
- Perfect for beginners
- User-friendly and hassle-free operation
- Effortless cleaning process
- A game-changing appliance for frozen pizza enthusiasts
- Ideal for those who enjoy take-and-bake or homemade pizza
- Even frozen pizzas yield a fluffy and airy crust, typically achieved by professional delivery services
What do people not like?
- The stone may appear to lose color over time, but this does not impact its taste or quality.
- Be mindful of the edges when frequently using and handling the stone – taking proper care is important.
ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone
Make amazing pizzas just like from the pizzeria with ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone! This cordierite stone is incredibly heat resistant – up to 1400°F! – so you can be sure to get an evenly cooked, crispy, delicious crust every time. Plus, you can also use it to bake bread, cookies, biscuits, and more.
Take your cooking skills up a notch with the innovative double-faced built-in handle design. This helps to save space and makes transferring the pizza stone easy.
And you don’t have to worry about harmful substances emanating from the pizza stone either – it’s made of food-grade stoneware that is burnt in a 2200°F kiln. Absolute perfection in terms of thickness, this ROCKSHEAT pizza stone is 0.63″ – just the right amount of sturdiness without extra weight.
For the optimal pizza-making experience, hand-wash your ROCKSHEAT Pizza Stone and you’re good to go. Now you can have restaurant-quality pizzas and savory baked goods at home – any time you want!
What do people like?
- Perfectly cooked pizza with a light and crisp crust.
- The stone can withstand very high heat, ensuring even and thorough cooking.
- No unpleasant odor while baking.
- Excellent quality stone.
- The handles are functional and convenient.
What do people not like?
- Melted cheese is a pain to clean off the stone.
- The stone has a good weight, but the handles should be offset for better balance when lifting.
Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack
Let your taste buds be transported to Italy with the Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack! Enjoy the fresh and crispy aroma of a thin-crust pizza, handmade with melted cheese and grilled toppings.
With the help of this incredible cordierite stone, you can now cook delicious pizzas, bread, and desserts right in the comfort of your backyard!
This pizza stone boasts superior heat absorption, ensuring optimal cooking results for your favorite pizza recipes. The included Carry Rack makes it incredibly easy to transport your pizza from the kitchen to the grill without any mess or fuss.
On top of being convenient, this special rack also fits perfectly into Weber’s Gourmet BBQ System cooking grate, keeping it securely in place while you cook.
Plus, this pizza stone is incredibly easy to care for. Simply hand wash after each use and watch it transform your favorite recipes into something magical.
Whether you’re cooking for a special occasion or simply looking for a fun night indoors, the Weber Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with Carry Rack is sure to please.
Try it for yourself and give your taste buds a treat—you’ll be saying ciao to everyone you know after they taste your authentic Italian-style pizza!
What do people like?
- Ideal size, thickness, and seasoning ability
- Versatile for both grilling and oven use
- Sturdy construction for long-lasting durability
- Easy to clean
- High-quality material
- Metal rack prevents damage to outdoor furniture when a hot stone is placed on it
- Compatible with a BBQ system and perfectly fits in with it.
What do people not like?
- Handles can be a hindrance: The handles on pizza stones are necessary for holding and lifting them, but they can also get in the way and limit accessibility when using a pizza paddle.
- Pricey but worth it: While pizza stones may be a bit expensive, the improvement in your pizza-making experience makes them an investment worth considering.
Char-Griller 6201 AKORN Kamado Grill Smokin’ Stone
The ultimate accessory package for your outdoor cooking needs! The Char-Griller 6201 AKORN Kamado Grill Smokin’ Stone is the perfect addition to your Char-Griller Kamado BBQ grill.
This ceramic stone is the #1 smoker accessory for AKORN Charcoal Grill and Smoker and will turn your barbecue into an outdoor convection oven.
The unique and stylish ivory hue will look good in any outdoor setting and with superior heat retention up to 1200 degrees, this stone will have you grilling and baking year-round!
Whether it’s smoking, baking, roasting, or grilling, the Char-Griller 6201 AKORN Kamado Grill Smokin’ Stone is reliable and versatile!
The stone was specially designed to diffuse heat around the perimeter of the grill, keeping your savory meats tender and juicy while you achieve the perfect char. This durable and easy-to-clean material is also dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze!
If you’re looking for the ultimate barbeque accessory to master all your outdoor cooking needs, the Char-Griller 6201 AKORN Kamado Grill Smokin’ Stone is the only choice for you!
With its stylish and unique design, superior heat retention, and eye-catching hue, grab this perfect amateur smoker accessory or gift it to the grill master in your life today!
What do people like?
- Affordable price
- Simple and user-friendly
- Perfect for slow low cooking
- Provides indirect heat for even cooking
- Keeps meat moist with added liquid
- Ensures consistent temperature control
- Sturdy and well-constructed
What do people not like?
- Does not fit the 18” Kamado properly, interfering with the primary grill rack.
- Sits too high in the heat box instead of being lower.
- Difficult to keep clean.
Buying Guide
Size and Shape
Are you looking to elevate your pizza game? The size and shape of your pizza stone play a crucial role. Whether you want to make larger pizzas or cook multiple pizzas at once, a larger stone would be ideal.
When it comes to finding the best pizza stone for Traeger grills, it’s essential to consider both the size of your grill and your personal preferences. You can choose from a range of sizes, starting from 12 inches in diameter and going up to 16 inches or more.
To ensure optimal cooking, it’s crucial to select a pizza stone that fits comfortably on the grill grates of your Traeger grill while allowing enough space for air to circulate.
A stone that is too large may obstruct the airflow, affecting the cooking process. Rest assured, all of the recommended pizza stones will fit perfectly on standard Traegers.
In terms of shape, round pizza stones are the most common. However, you also have the option of rectangular or square-shaped stones. The choice ultimately comes down to your personal preference and the shape of your Traeger grill.
For round Traeger grill grates, go for a round pizza stone that ensures excellent air circulation. If you prefer making larger pizzas or batches of flatbreads, a rectangular stone will provide you with more surface area.
When determining the size, remember to measure the diameter of your Traeger grill and choose a stone that is 2-3 inches smaller to allow for proper airflow.
Standard sizes include 14″, 15″, and 16″, in both round and rectangular shapes. For those craving even bigger pizzas and batches, consider an extra-large stone measuring 20″ x 13.5″.
Upgrade your pizza experience with the perfect size and shape of a pizza stone for your Traeger grill. Don’t settle for the ordinary when you can have the extraordinary.
Materials
Choosing the right material for your pizza stone is crucial. There are several options available, each with its unique qualities and care requirements. Let’s explore the top materials:
1) Cordierite: One popular material is cordierite, often used to make beautiful kiln shelves. Its high heat tolerance makes it an excellent baking surface. Cordierite absorbs moisture, resulting in a crispy and delicious crust.
2) Ceramic: If you prefer a lighter option, ceramic pizza stones made from clay are recommended. While they take longer to heat up and cool down, they offer a crisp crust and keep your pizza warm for longer.
3) Cast Iron: Cast iron is a durable and heat-resistant material that is perfect for making pizza and baking bread. It can withstand thermal shock and retain heat, keeping your pizza hot for a long time.
Ultimately, prioritize a high-quality, food-grade material that can withstand the intense temperatures of a Traeger grill without any risk of damage. Choose the best pizza stone for Traeger grills wisely for the perfect pizza experience.
Thickness
The thickness of a pizza stone plays a crucial role in its performance. Thicker stones have several advantages, including better heat retention and more even cooking.
While they may take longer to heat up, their ability to distribute heat evenly makes them ideal for cooking. Thinner stones, on the other hand, heat up faster but struggle to retain heat effectively and are more prone to cracking.
When it comes to thickness, 1-inch stones are the best choice for cooking. They are heavier and more durable, ensuring they can withstand the demands of regular use.
Despite taking longer to heat up, these thicker stones excel at conducting heat. As a result, they distribute heat evenly, leading to pizzas that are cooked consistently throughout.
In contrast, thinner stones, which measure 1/4″, heat up quickly but fail to retain heat efficiently. They are also more susceptible to cracking.
For those seeking crispy crusts, thicker stones, ranging from 1/2″ to 1″, are the preferred option. Although they require a longer preheating time, their superior heat retention capabilities result in perfectly crisp crusts.
To maximize the performance of your pizza stone, consider opting for a thicker option that offers excellent heat retention and even cooking.
Heat Capacity
For that perfect homemade pizza, having the best pizza stone for Traeger grills that can withstand and efficiently conduct high temperatures is essential.
Achieving temperatures of 600 to 900 degrees is the sweet spot for a mouthwatering crispy crust. Preheating the stone over a grill is highly recommended to ensure optimum heat control, particularly for thicker stones.
To fully unleash the pizza stone’s potential, it is advised to heat it continuously for at least one hour. This will guarantee that your pizza comes out flawlessly cooked, with a delectable crust that will leave your taste buds begging for more.
Weight
When it comes to choosing a stone for baking, weight matters. Lighter stones, weighing between 3-5 lbs, offer the advantage of heating up quickly.
However, they may be more susceptible to cracking. On the other hand, heavier stones, weighing 6lbs or more, retain heat better, resulting in more consistent baking. The downside is that they take longer to preheat.
Additionally, it’s important to note that heavy stones can be bulkier to handle. Consider opting for stones with handles to make your baking experience more convenient.
Long-Lasting Durability.
Invest in quality pizza stones that will withstand the test of time. With proper care, these stones can serve you for years to come, thanks to their exceptional durability and thermal shock resistance that prevents unsightly cracks.
Consider options like cordierite and steel, which are known for their outstanding durability. However, if you’re looking for a practically indestructible pizza stone, cast iron is the way to go, especially when properly seasoned.
Choose durability and invest in a pizza stone that will stand firm through countless delicious pizza-making adventures.
Easy to use
Safely transfer your hot stones from the grill to the tabletop with ease, thanks to the convenient handles.
Effortlessly load and unload your pizzas, and even rotate them while baking, with the help of our practical pizza peels.
Maintenance
Properly using and maintaining your best pizza stone for Traeger grills is crucial. These high-temperature stones require adequate cooling before cleaning. Even when making bread, it’s important to let the stone cool down before removing any stubborn residue.
Additionally, avoid the risk of thermal shock by never submerging a super hot pizza stone in water. This can result in cracks and chips. Whether you’re using steel or ceramic pizza stones, it’s recommended to carefully adhere to the maintenance instructions.
Some stones may require seasoning or specific cleaning methods, while others may be dishwasher-safe. Choose a stone that aligns with your lifestyle and cooking preferences.
Price
When selecting a Traeger pizza stone, price is a crucial factor to consider. While it is important not to overspend, investing in a high-quality stone that will endure is paramount. Remember, a higher price often signifies superior materials and construction.
Conclusion
After testing out these nine options for the best pizza stone for Traeger grills, we have managed to find a clear winner in Cast Elegance Durable Thermal Shock Resistant Thermarite Pizza and Baking Stone.
Not only is it designed to fit perfectly into your Traeger grill, but it also has a porous surface that allows for excellent heat distribution while also making sure you get that perfect crispy crust on your pizzas.
Additionally, its thermal shock-resistant material ensures the stone will hold up in those hot Temperate settings yet still stay lightweight and durable. With its affordable price tag, this is one of the best bargains available on today’s market if you are looking for a great pizza stone for your Traeger grill.
With all that said, we can confidently recommend this product as the best option among the nine options tested out. So what do you think?
Will you be trying Cast Elegance’s Durable Thermal Shock-resistant Thermarite Pizza and Baking Stone? What is your final verdict? Let us know your opinion about this pizza stone in the comments below!
Thanks for reading our article. If you want to know more information, visit our website here.
Read more:
How often should you replace a pizza stone?
How to Use a Pizza Stone (with Pictures) – wikiHow Life
When do you replace pizza stones?
I’m Vance Douglas, and I love making pizza. In fact, I love it so much that I decided to build my own oven to make it in. It’s a brick oven that I made myself, and it’s the best pizza oven you’ll ever find.
Making pizza is a passion of mine, and I’m always looking for new ways to make it even better. I’ve been making pizza for years, and I continue to learn more about the art every day. My goal is to create the perfect pizza, and I’m getting closer and closer every time.
